Breathing shapes how you feel every day, especially if you deal with anxiety, asthma, or restless nights. This has made breathwork quite popular for improving physical health, mental clarity, and emotional balance.
With numerous breathing methods available, selecting the right one can be overwhelming. Buteyko and Soma Breath are two approaches that promise to help you breathe easier and live healthier lives. While both have their own appeal, only one is concretely backed by decades of clinical experience and real-world results - the Buteyko Method.
Today’s article provides a detailed comparison between Buteyko and Soma breathing, covering their origins, techniques, physiological effects, benefits, limitations, and practical applications.
Origins and Foundational Philosophies
We begin by exploring the origins and philosophies of these two breathwork methods:
Buteyko Breathing
The Buteyko Breathing Method began in the 1950s with Ukrainian physician Dr. Konstantin Buteyko. While studying medicine in Moscow, Dr. Buteyko noticed that people with chronic health issues like asthma and high blood pressure often breathed faster than healthy people.
He realized that this habit of overbreathing disturbed the natural balance of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the body, often exacerbating symptoms. Dr. Buteyko tested this on himself, slowing his own breath and finding that it helped lower his blood pressure. This led him to develop a method to help others restore healthy breathing patterns.
Buteyko’s approach is grounded in clinical science and focuses on retraining the way we breathe using gentle, structured exercises. There have been a number of scientific studies done on the Buteyko method, which had proven its effectiveness and use.
In 2003, a controlled clinical trial published in the New Zealand Medical Journal demonstrated that adults with asthma who practiced Buteyko reduced their inhaled steroid use by 50% and their beta2-agonist use by 85%, with no adverse events, indicating that the method is both safe and effective.
While in 2017, another randomized controlled trial in children found that the Buteyko Method improved lung function and quality of life.
Soma Breathing
Soma Breathing is a newer, less widely studied method. It is a more recent breathwork system created by Niraj Naik, a former pharmacist who turned to holistic health after overcoming his own chronic illness.
Inspired by ancient yogic breathing and modern neuroscience, Soma Breath mixes rhythmic breathing, breath holds, movement, music, and guided visualization. The name “Soma” comes from a mythical elixir in Vedic tradition, believed to bring bliss and vitality. This reflects Soma Breath’s focus on personal transformation and higher states of awareness.
Soma Breath is designed to be flexible and holistic, with practices that can be tailored to individual needs. Sessions are often done in groups and focus on creating a supportive community.
While Soma Breath is less established in mainstream science, new research, including studies at Cambridge University, is beginning to examine its effects on brain activity, mood, and mental well-being.
Core Techniques and Practices
Below are the core techniques and principles of Buteyko and Soma breath:
Buteyko Method
Buteyko vs Soma Breath techniques differ significantly in their approach. The Buteyko Method is structured and systematic, built on these key components:
- Nasal Breathing: All breathing is done through the nose, which filters, warms, and humidifies air, supporting better oxygen delivery and airway health.
- Reduced Breathing: Practitioners learn to take smaller, quieter breaths to prevent over-breathing and maintain healthy carbon dioxide levels.
- Breath Holds (Control Pause): After a gentle exhale, the breath is held until the first natural urge to breathe. This “Control Pause” is repeated and used as a measure of breathing efficiency, longer pauses indicate healthier breathing patterns.
- Relaxation: Techniques are included to promote relaxation, prevent over-breathing during stress, and break the cycle of hyperventilation.
A typical Buteyko session involves sitting upright, relaxing the breathing muscles, and practicing cycles of nasal breathing and breath holds. The method is particularly valued for its clinical foundation and measurable results.
Soma Breathing
Soma Breath, in contrast, is more dynamic and multisensory. Soma breathing exercises combine several elements:
- Rhythmic Breathing: Sessions use cycles of deep, rhythmic inhalations and exhalations, often followed by breath retention. This creates a wave-like effect intended to energize both body and mind.
- Breath Retention: Breath holds are integrated into longer, flowing sequences, sometimes accompanied by movement or chanting.
- Movement and Music: Soma sessions often feature music, gentle movement, and guided visualization, making it a rich, immersive experience.
- Emotional Release: The method is designed to facilitate emotional catharsis and spiritual awakening, with many reporting profound emotional shifts.
Benefits and Applications
Both the Buteyko Method and Soma Breath offer unique health benefits and practical applications, so here’s what each can do for you:
Health Benefits of Buteyko Breathing
- Respiratory health: Buteyko is clinically proven to help manage asthma and improve breathing in those with chronic respiratory issues, often reducing symptoms and medication use.
- Stress and anxiety reduction: This method promotes calm by retraining dysfunctional breathing patterns, making it easier to manage anxiety and everyday stress.
- Improved sleep: By encouraging nasal breathing and reducing over-breathing, Buteyko can improve sleep quality and help with snoring or sleep apnea.
- Blood pressure regulation: Practicing Buteyko may help lower and stabilize blood pressure through slower, lighter, and more controlled breathing.
- Enhanced focus and energy: More efficient breathing leads to better oxygen delivery, which can boost mental clarity, alertness, and daily energy levels.
- Better breathing habits: The method supports a shift from chronic mouth breathing to healthier nasal breathing, improving overall respiratory function.
Health Benefits of Soma Breath
- Emotional release and mental clarity: Soma Breath sessions are designed to help you process emotions deeply, often leaving you with a clearer and more focused mind.
- Stress reduction: The rhythmic breathing, paired with music and guided visualization, creates a powerful relaxation effect that melts away stress.
- Physical vitality: Combining breathwork with movement, Soma Breath can boost your energy, stamina, and overall physical well-being.
- Self-discovery and confidence: Many practitioners find that Soma Breath enhances self-esteem, confidence, and a sense of mind-body connection.
- Enhanced resilience: Regular practice helps you manage stress better and build greater emotional resilience for daily life.
Safety and Suitability
Let us briefly take a look ast the safety guidelines for both methods:
Buteyko Breathing:
Buteyko is considered safe for most people, including those with chronic health conditions like asthma or high blood pressure. Since the method involves gentle nasal breathing and moderate breath holds, it’s generally well-tolerated.
However, beginners may feel discomfort or anxiety if they push too hard, so it’s best to learn from a certified instructor and stop if you feel unwell. Buteyko is not recommended for people with severe respiratory illnesses, unstable heart conditions, or during the first trimester of pregnancy. Always consult a healthcare professional if you have concerns.
Soma Breath:
Is Soma breathing safe? For most healthy adults, Soma Breath is generally safe, especially when practiced at a comfortable pace. However, the breath retention and more intense exercises may not be suitable for everyone, particularly those with heart conditions, epilepsy, or during pregnancy. If you’re unsure about your suitability for Soma Breath, it’s wise to consult a professional before starting.
Training and Accessibility
For one who wants to learn the breathing methods or become a breathwork practitioner, here is brief info on their training:
Buteyko Breathing:
Buteyko training is widely accessible through certified clinics and a range of online courses, many of which are medically endorsed. Learning from a certified breathwork instructor ensures you practice safely, get the most benefit, and are able to teach others. You can explore certification options and find instructors easily through the Buteyko Clinic website.
Soma Breath:
Soma Breath offers training through online programs, workshops, and facilitator certification courses. How much is Soma Breath training? Pricing varies depending on the course format, with options for group classes, private sessions, and instructor training. You can find detailed information about programs and costs on the Soma Breath website.
Buteyko vs Soma Breath: Key Differences
Here is a table showing the main differences between Buteyko and Soma breath
| Aspect | Buteyko Breathing | Soma Breath |
|---|---|---|
| Origins | Developed in the 1950s by Dr. Konstantin Buteyko, rooted in clinical medicine | Created by Niraj Naik, inspired by ancient yogic and modern wellness practices |
| Scientific Support | Backed by strong clinical research for asthma, sleep, anxiety, and blood pressure | Limited scientific studies; benefits mostly anecdotal or experiential |
| Main Techniques | Gentle nasal breathing, reduced breath volume, breath holds, relaxation | Rhythmic deep breathing, longer breath retention, music, movement, visualization |
| Health Benefits | Proven relief for asthma, better sleep, reduced anxiety, improved focus, stabilized blood pressure | Reported mood boost, emotional release, more energy, and stress reduction |
| Overall Approach | Structured, gentle, health-focused, and medically endorsed | Dynamic, experiential, group-oriented, and self-exploratory |
Buteyko Breathing is the Smart Choice
When it comes to choosing a breathwork method that truly supports your health, Buteyko stands out for its proven results and medical credibility. Decades of research and clinical use show that Buteyko reliably improves one’s health.
This is a method trusted by healthcare professionals and used by people worldwide to manage chronic conditions and establish a foundation for improved breathing for life.
If you want a safe, structured, and effective approach that is supported by science, Buteyko is the clear answer. Its gentle techniques are accessible to most people and can lead to real, lasting improvements in your wellbeing.
For anyone serious about taking control of their health and making a meaningful difference in their quality of life, Buteyko is the method that delivers.
Take Control of Your Breath with Buteyko
You have seen the facts: Buteyko is a breathwork method backed by rigorous science that consistently improves asthma, sleep, anxiety, and blood pressure. This is a method designed for real people facing real health challenges, not just a wellness fad.
World renowned breathing expert and founder of Buteyko Clinic International, Patrick McKeown, has made this powerful technique accessible worldwide. Our online courses provide expert guidance for beginners and advanced practitioners alike.
The certification programs empower instructors to share this life changing method globally, while their range of breathing support products ensures every practitioner has the tools needed for success.
ALSO READ:
